Skip to content

The Rose and the Beast: Fairy Tales Retold

November 8, 2010

The Rose and the Beast: Fairy Tales Retold

By Francesca Lia Block

Published 2001

Synopsis:

A collection of nine different stories loosely based on classic fairy tales but set in modern day.

Review:

One of my favorite kinds of stories is the re-imaginings of old fairy tales.  The master of fairytale retellings, in my opinion, is Gail Carson Levine. In a way, I’m such a huge Levine fan that I don’t think Francesca Lia Block’s book stood a chance right from the start.  I was hoping for more of the same unique, empowering, totally delightful perspective I found in Levine’s Princess Tales.  But with that style firmly implanted in my brain’s “LOVE IT” section, I could never quite fall for Block’s book because the two styles are so extremely different. 

Here’s what I liked about this book: The rhythmic writing; it was told almost in free verse.  The stories were told in the same way that a beatnik would tell them on a dark stage in a small theater while smoking a cigarette and wearing a black tunic.  I also liked the daring—Block touched on much deeper emotion and passion than any of Levine’s books.  She is not afraid to address abuse and addiction in a very personal way.

Here’s what I didn’t like: It was at times a little too graphic for my taste; but that’s not to say that it wouldn’t appeal to a lot of young adults.  It’s just not my personal preference.  I don’t care for the gritty L.A. underworld setting, with reference to drug use by young kids in such a way that makes it sound like an understandably necessary part of life if you are a victim of abuse.  I don’t think all victims of abuse must inevitably become drug addicts and prostitutes.  But, again, this is a world that I can’t fairly comment on since I’m neither a victim of abuse nor a teenager living in L.A.

There is no denying that the writing was high quality; it’s just the subject matter that I wasn’t crazy about.

Recommendations:

Ages 14 and up; pre-teens should not be reading this. There are intimate, graphic descriptions of adult matters and an overall theme of confusing feelings of sexual attractions.  I can’t see myself saying to a teen, “hey, you should really read these retold fairy tales that depict heroines as teenagers struggling to cope with abuse, sex, fantasies, drug addiction, and harsh realities…”

Rating:

2 ½ boots.  Just because it’s not my idea of a great book to curl up with doesn’t mean I don’t think teens would enjoy this.  I do think Block is extremely gifted with language and writing style.  A friend once highly recommended Block’s first book Weetzie Bat to me and even though I didn’t love The Rose and the Beast, I’m still very open to reading more by this author, if only to enjoy more of that unique lyrical style she has.

From → Book Treks

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

BookTrekker

Dedicated to books, travels, and the stories that bring them together.

Unbound Pages

Book Reviews for Kids and Young Adults

The Guardian

Book Reviews for Kids and Young Adults

Big Book Little Book

A book review blog dedicated to the books we enjoy ourselves and the books we love to share with our children.

Forever Young Adult

Book Reviews for Kids and Young Adults

The Forest of Words and Pages

Two bookish nerds reviewing the words and pages we read.

Twenty Three Pages

Books. Beauty. Life.

%d bloggers like this: